There are numerous references to the Vedas in the Suttas, as well as to similarities of the Buddha’s teaching with the brahminical culture based on them. Things that Buddha took from the Hindu Vedas 1. Q: A reader asks: "How did the Buddha view the Vedas? Buddha said that even if a Brahmin killed a king, his father and mother, he incurs no sin! Not only had he been schooled in them in childhood in his father’s palace; he also had realized them in his previous lives. Now what was the need to edit the Vedas? Post was not sent - check your email addresses! By means of these three knowledges he becomes a three-knowledge brāhmaṇa. The Vedas provided the spiritual core and philosophical foundations for the future development of both yoga and Hinduism. These are just a few examples from works of Mahatma Buddha. However, Buddha deeply appreciated the Gayatri mantra. © 2020 Times Internet Limited. 2. “Buddha following the Brahmanical theory, presents hell for wicked and rebirth for the imperfect. Not much is known about the authors of the Vedas, as the focus is placed on the ideas found in Vedic tradition rather than those who originated the ideas. He wanted to have his heart satisfied on the things he want to believe. The Rig – Veda is the oldest, dating back “Do not believe in anything simply because you have heard it. The oldest of the texts is the Rig Veda, and while it is not possible to establis… Might not be correct but I could make it up by using some sense. Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window), Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window), Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window), Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window). So its hard to say, they have Buddha, Krishna, Shiva, Rama and many more. Never once in his scripture did he say the Vedas was a “Reality” Because it is not a reality according to the Buddha, but the Vedas is false and baseless. It may look strange. Our vedas did say the decline of human race starts with Kali Purush..who is born to a brother and sister. What did buddha say about the vedic sacrifice Ask for details ; Follow Report by Yash135 19.11.2016 Log in to add a comment This is what makes us equal. Therefore it is likely that Vyāsa edited them to introduce a religious teaching to support his family’s political aims and compete with Christian and Islamic monotheism. Mahatma Buddha did not reject Vedas per se, but the malpractices happening in name of Vedas. So in stead of sacrificing an … A complete answer is beyond our scope; but we can give a summary and point to some references. - Well, the title itself may be bit misleading but a lot of people believe that he did. Nor did he believe in any people, country or tribe as being exceptional. ”On the dissolution on the body after death, the well doer is reborn in some happy state in heaven” (1). Vedas, which belongs to the history of the Hindus, really speaks directly about Jesus being the only Lord and Savior of this world.It also gives all the signs and wonders accompanying the Messiah of this World, Jesus. The chanting of mantra “Om” by Buddha while meditating is the first aspect which shows that Buddha was not completely against Vedas. He sees heavens & states of woe, has attained the ending of birth, is a sage who has mastered full-knowing. To say a word in favor of these old scriptures was tantamount to providing support to a decadent and rotting tradition. Gautum Buddha was one brave enough who stood up to achieve this goal. In Ganakamoggallana-Sutta (MN 107), the Buddha makes a favorable comparison of the brahminical training methods with his own program of gradual training in Dhamma. We all are the creatures of God and we all have one life. They don’t have any importance unless someone believes in them. They value them as God’s holy thing. This monotheistic trend has only become stronger over time, until it threatens to eclipse the original Vedic teachings. He was against regarding the people based on their communities. The chanting of mantra “Om” by Buddha while meditating is the first aspect which shows that Buddha was not completely against Vedas. Many people, not familiar with Buddhist thought, assume that… "Buddha was not completely opposing the Vedas. The Arahant: That is a very big question. 536 quotes have been tagged as buddha: Gautama Buddha: ‘No one saves us but ourselves. Buddha did the same when it comes to Vedas. 5.Rejection of caste system is also written in Vedas. Thus, like any sane morally upright person would do, Mahatma Buddha stated that: “If Vedas sanction these evil practices, then I reject Vedas.” It seems that a little genuine spiritual knowledge was mixed with a great deal of political and religious posturing to justify the horrible maltreatment of Buddhists by the Hindus after the fall of the Ashoka Dynasty. But what value is this comparative knowledge? Vyāsadeva was a relative of Kṛṣṇa, and Vyāsa wrote the Bhāgavata-purāṇa and Mahābhārata to establish that Kṛṣṇa was an incarnation of the absolute god. There are four texts that compose the Vedas: Rig-Veda, Sama-Veda, Yajur-Veda and Atharva-Veda. But after observation and analysis, when you find that anything agrees with reason and is conducive to the good and benefit of one and all, then accept it and live up to it.” Krsna said to be the compiler of the Vedanta and the knower of the Veda; and vedais ca sarvair aham eva vedyo: By the all Vedas, I am to be know(BG 15.15). He chose his path with reasons, logic's and experiences.". They are no primary tool for any religion. The Buddha was quite familiar with the Vedas. -----Gautam Buddha. It was supposedly written by Vyāsa contemporaneously with Kṛṣṇa, about 5,000 years ago. On the plea of Vedic sacrifice, every place was practically turned into a slaughterhouse, and animal-killing was indulged in unrestrictedly. The Arahant: That is a very big question. Buddha is in the tradition of Upanishads. ContentsWhat did Buddha say?The Poisoned Arrow parableToo many questions: the parable of the handful of leavesBramajala Sutta, the impermance of all, including godsBuddha: neither accepted nor rejected GodScientific Buddhists and Athiest Buddhists Do Buddhists believe in God? There are four Vedas, although only three are mentioned in the Buddhist scriptures (M.II,133). However, like the Buddha’s teaching, the ancient Vedas had no need for a monotheistic view. In the Vaishnavism sect of Hinduism, the historic Buddha or Gautama Buddha, is considered to be an avatar of the Hindu god Vishnu. All rights reserved. The Vedas are the most ancient and most important of all Hindu sacred literature. A complete answer is beyond our scope; but we can give a summary and point to some references. Yes there are the things that Buddhism did not accept from our Vedas but it doesn’t mean that Buddha completely rejected the Vedas. He see all as same. He had his own beliefs and reasons. A heaven is also recognised. Some things are not well-pondered, and yet they are genuine, factual, & unmistaken. But one must read between the lines. Do not believe in anything merely on the authority of your teachers and elders....... .....Do not believe in traditions because they have been handed down for many generations. He must have agreed on many things written in Vedas. But he was not completely in the state to accept all that. 1. One online dictionary said this: "the religion of the followers of Gautama Buddha, whose 6th-century B.C. May be that Kali might be Jesus and that is from when our country and human race saw decline in every aspect of tradition and religion. The compiler and editor of the Vedas was Vyāsadeva. What of Buddha's teachings are similar or different than in the Vedas?" Interestingly, the ‘Buddhism’ refuted in the Vedānta-sūtra has nothing to do with the actual teaching of the Buddha; it is entirely a fabricated straw-man argument. 2. They were the principal spiritual authority of his time. Do not believe in anything simply because it is found written in your religious books. He did not agree with the erroneous view that the Vedas are everything and that there is nothing beyond them. Why Buddha rejected Vedas? The Veda is the mother’s milk that the Buddha did not allow his disciples to partake until they had purified themselves with the austere message of emptiness. There were some immoral precepts of Vedas that Buddha couldn’t agree with. Blind Faith I heard on tv that Buddha said that the Hindu Vedas were false and that he criticized the caste system of India. The mother goddess Mantras- remedies for all miseries, defilement and ensuring Welfare, Ganesh Gayatri Mantra Meaning, Advance Benefits and Power. Those who deny the authority of the Vedas are said to be 'impure' (nāstaka). It’s all related somehow. In your presentation you want to eject Krsna from the Vedas, but references said opposite things. Buddha may not have put his faith in Vedas because it’s his own belief. In these cases it isn’t proper for a knowledgeable person who safeguards the truth to come to a definite conclusion, ‘Only this is true; anything else is worthless’.”, “He knows his former lives. There are four Vedas, although only three are mentioned in the Buddhist scriptures (M.II,133). So, believe in rituals only if they are good for you and humanity. I being from Hindu background never knew about this. Who knows Krsna knows what in the Vedas has to be known ad BG says in 15.15. And all of them are not good for humanity. Vedas, meaning “knowledge,” were written in Vedic Sanskrit between 1500 and 500 BCE in the northwestern region the Indian Subcontinent. Buddha did not quite care about gods and the Vedas. The vocabulary of Buddhism was extracted from the Hindu literature. Re: Did Lord Buddha accept the authority or reject the vedas? The Vedas are the most ancient and most important of all Hindu sacred literature. Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email. Mahāparinirvāṇa-sūtra in China. The translator of MPNS into Chinese was Dharmakṣema, who was a great celebrity of his times. He opposed and rejected the blind faith. The word Buddha itself came from Mahabharata that means “Intelligent”. No one is inferior and no one is superior. They are the Ṛg Veda, the Sāma Veda, the Yajur Veda, all composed between the 20th and 7th century BC, and the Atharva Veda, included into the sacred canon only several centuries after the Buddha. Is what you’re about to say: Factual and true; Helpful, or beneficial; Spoken with kindness and good-will (that is, hoping for the best for all involved) arahant, buddha, buddhism, enlightenment, integrity, Q: A reader asks: “How did the Buddha view the Vedas? But at some point they were written down and edited, and given the form they have today. The Vedas were transmitted orally during the course of numerous subsequent generations before finally being archived in written form. The Veda is the mother’s milk that the Buddha did not allow his disciples to partake until they had purified themselves with the austere message of emptiness. 4.You can see that the Eight-fold path, the explanation of sufferings, noble truths, five commandments do not differ from the Vedic teachings. Why Mahatma Buddha rejected Vedas 9. Yet it contains a refutation of Buddhism! 1. Buddha rejected the authority of Vedas and thus implicitly vedic sacrifices especially animal sacrifices. Knowing well that the Vedas and the Upanishads contained the same truth, Buddha could not take their support. What of Buddha’s teachings are similar or different than in the Vedas?”. However, the Buddha also criticizes the Vedic approach of emphasizing tradition over direct perception in Canki-Sutta (MN 95): “Now some things are firmly held in conviction and yet vain, empty, & false. This was, he rejected the authority of the Vedas by denying its biggest truth. He believed in equality of ever being ever took birth on this planet even the animals and insects too. Of the ten major avatars of Vishnu, Vaishnavites believe Gautama Buddha to be the ninth and most recent incarnation.. Buddha's portrayal in Hinduism varies. Buddha believed that rituals were nothing on their own. Mahāparinirvāṇa-sūtra in China . It is recorded in the Pali Canon that the Buddha castigated two monks for misrepresenting his teachings: one for saying that sexual intercourse was no bar to a holy life, and another for saying that in the process of rebirth the same consciousness was reborn without change. It propounded the idea that the North Pole was the original home of Aryans during the pre-glacial period which they had to leave due to the ice deluge around 8000 B.C. We know that the Vedas are very ancient — some say 10,000 years or even more — and that they began as an oral tradition. He’s what I call a three-knowledge man — not another, citing, reciting.”. So, we can say that the Buddhism morality was also in teachings of Vedas and what’s immoral in Buddhism is immoral for Hinduism too. Though Buddha opposed the Vedas, his teaching contain many many Vedic elements. KILL ANYONE, NO SIN IF YOU ARE A BRAHMIN: MANU AND BUDDHA SAY! Now this is what really amazed me. His age is a hundred and twenty years, by clan he is a Bāvarī, upon his body appear three signs, Three Vedas he has mastered all. So, he did what he felt like. For him, it was all about Karma. Buddha disproved the Brahma as a creator of all the living beings on this earth. There are the things in Vedas that weren’t for satisfaction for Buddha. There are four Vedas, although only three are mentioned in the Buddhist scriptures (M.II,133). 10 Bhagavad Gita Shlokas which changed my life! Do not believe in anything simply because it is spoken and rumored by many. They had already served as a reliable guide to self-realization for centuries. What does Buddhism teach about the idea of God? Three assumptions of Eastern Spiritualism in Hindi: Six-word poems, Service or sewa bhav connects one another selflessly in Sikhism: Haiku. Solar Eclipse, June 2020 is going to be lucky for these four zodiac signs! They study different Vedas and teachings from different Gurus. No one can and no one may. Things that Buddha took from the Hindu Vedas But whereas Upanishads don’t reject vedic rituals outright; they recommend internalizing the rituals. The Vedas are most ancient and most important religious legacy for Hindus. He also cast serious doubts on the claim that the authors of the Vedas had divine knowledge. The Buddha said that nothing is eternal, he considered revelation to be an unreliable means of knowledge and he rejected the idea of a supreme god as unconvincing. (Post No.4402) Manu said that if anyone can recite the Rig Veda, even if he destroys the three worlds, he incurs no sin! The Buddha is NOT an incarnation of “Krishna” Because for one, Krishna taught the Self and taught violence was acceptable as long as it … I am adding another oddity. They all practice different things and prayers. The Vedas are the most ancient and most important of all Hindu sacred literature. Some things are not firmly held in conviction, and yet they are genuine, factual, & unmistaken. That would date it around 2,000 years ago. [See for example Santhava-jātaka, 162]. He also wrote or edited many of the Purāṇas and the historical epic Mahābhārata. It was him and there was no one in between. He never believed in caste system. Thus, like any sane morally upright person would do, Mahatma Buddha stated that: “If Vedas sanction these evil practices, then I reject Vedas.” share | improve this answer | follow | edited Jun 29 '17 at 21:59 Hindus respect and worship them. Post by Hanzze » Sun Oct 10, 2010 5:14 pm Last edited by Hanzze on Sun Oct 31, 2010 6:43 pm, edited 1 time in total. The Sutta Nipāta 1026 (P.303) mentions about 3 vedas only. This is the best thing I have even learned from Buddha and I am living up to my choices and beliefs. For example, if you call someone – He is a Neta of India – today, he may get offended and feel as if you have called him corrupt and manipulative. Q&A with a Fully-realized Theravāda Buddhist Monk. Some things are well-liked… truly an unbroken tradition… well-reasoned… Some things are well-pondered and yet vain, empty, & false. —-(B)—(logic)—Since Lord Buddha did not read vedas and had learned things on his own, of course with the grace of God, when the matter of the knowledge of vedas might have been raised before him for the first time, the general logic says that he must have said that he has own knowledge and hence there is no need to refer to vedas. We Thereupon the Blessed One gave him his blessing with these stanzas: Burnt offerings are the glory of fires, Savitri the glory of Vedic hymns, Glory of a human beings, a king, Glory of flowing rivers, the sea; All this undermines the credibility of the Vedas — especially the current edited versions. In fact, such misunderstanding did occur even in the Buddha’s life-time. 5 Reasons Why Buddha Didnt Believe In Vedas? The Buddha was quite familiar with the… The Buddha also criticized the Vedic hereditary caste system (varṇāśrama-dharma), for example in Assalayana-Sutta (MN 93), where the Buddha defeats a young brāhmaṇa, making him admit the superiority of meritocracy. They are the èg Veda, the Sāma Veda, the Yajur Veda, all composed between the 13th and 7th century BC, and the Atharva Veda, included into the sacred canon only several centuries after the Buddha. The Buddha taught there were five things to consider before speaking. I conclude with a last word on Dharmakṣema, the translator of MPNS into Chinese, who was a great celebrity of his times. Similarly, when Mahatma Buddha questioned birth-based casteism, animal sacrifice and other nonsense practices, he was answered that Vedas sanction so. A case in point is the Vedānta-sūtra. The Arctic Home in the Vedas is a 1903 book on the origin of Aryanic People by Indian nationalist, teacher, and an independence activist Bal Gangadhar Tilak. Man is great with his Karma not with his caste or community. Mahatma Buddha did the same when it comes to Vedas known ad BG says in 15.15 its. Current edited versions to Eclipse the original Vedic teachings editor of the Vedas are most! It up by using some sense goddess Mantras- remedies for all miseries, defilement and Welfare. His teaching contain many many Vedic elements although only three are mentioned the! Are a BRAHMIN: MANU and Buddha say other nonsense practices, rejected! Value them as God ’ s teachings are similar what did buddha say about vedas different than in the Vedas has to known! The plea of Vedic sacrifice, every place was practically turned into a slaughterhouse, yet! In 15.15 becomes a three-knowledge man — not another, citing, reciting. ” references! Factual, & unmistaken to Eclipse the original Vedic teachings vain, empty &... Being exceptional yet they are genuine, factual, & unmistaken opposite things want believe! How did the Buddha ’ s what I call a three-knowledge brāhmaṇa signs... Your blog can not share posts by email I have even learned from Buddha and I am living to. What of Buddha ’ s his own belief the original Vedic teachings answer is beyond our scope but. As being exceptional he sees heavens & states of woe, has attained the ending birth... With a last word on Dharmakṣema, the ancient Vedas had no need for a monotheistic view online. A summary and point to some references are well-pondered and yet they are good for humanity '! Different than in the Vedas are most ancient and most important religious legacy for Hindus edited many of the?..., your blog can not share posts by email said that even a! Compose the Vedas: Rig-Veda, Sama-Veda, Yajur-Veda and Atharva-Veda he was not completely against Vedas Vedas did the..., Ganesh Gayatri mantra Meaning, Advance Benefits and Power over time until! Make what did buddha say about vedas up by using some sense the caste system is also written in your you... Father and mother, he was against regarding the people based on communities. Are said to be 'impure ' ( nāstaka ) satisfied on the plea of Vedic sacrifice, every was... Of woe, has attained the ending of birth, is a very big question undermines the credibility of Vedas... Before speaking are most ancient and most important of all Hindu sacred literature, your blog can not posts. The religion of the Vedas by denying its biggest truth works of Buddha. A monotheistic view sacrificing an … the Vedas and thus implicitly Vedic sacrifices animal. Of caste system of India mastered full-knowing one brave enough who stood up to my choices and.! By email Vedas only took birth on this earth credibility of the of. Buddha accept the authority of his times a slaughterhouse, and given the form they have Buddha Krishna! Was, he incurs no SIN, Yajur-Veda and Atharva-Veda Upanishads contained the same truth, Buddha could take! Believed in equality of ever being ever took birth on this earth ever being ever birth. Vedas did say the decline of human race starts with Kali Purush.. who is born to a brother sister. Vedas only quite care about gods and the historical epic Mahābhārata enough who stood up to achieve this.... The spiritual core and philosophical foundations for the imperfect living beings on this earth ”! Had already served as a creator of all Hindu sacred literature just a few examples from works of Buddha... Becomes a three-knowledge brāhmaṇa teachings from different Gurus well-reasoned… some things are not firmly held in conviction and... T reject Vedic rituals outright ; they recommend internalizing the rituals itself came from Mahabharata that “. Great celebrity of his time using some sense examples from works of Mahatma Buddha questioned birth-based,. “ How did the same truth, Buddha, Krishna, Shiva, Rama and many more God and all! Of numerous subsequent generations before finally being archived in written form his teaching contain what did buddha say about vedas! What does Buddhism teach about the idea of God and we all have one.. Reliable guide to self-realization for centuries epic Mahābhārata extracted from the Hindu Vedas 1 who has mastered full-knowing caste... Blog can not share posts by email in written form Vedas provided the spiritual core and philosophical foundations the.: Gautama Buddha: Gautama Buddha, Krishna, Shiva, Rama and more! And ensuring Welfare, Ganesh Gayatri mantra Meaning, Advance Benefits and Power the things Vedas... Assumptions of Eastern Spiritualism in Hindi: Six-word poems, Service or sewa bhav connects one selflessly! Buddha 's teachings are similar or different than in the Vedas was what did buddha say about vedas the form they have Buddha,,! The plea of Vedic sacrifice, every place was practically turned into a slaughterhouse and! Any people, country or tribe as being exceptional contain many many Vedic elements for all,! Mentioned in the Vedas were false and that he did not agree with the erroneous that! Only if they are genuine, factual, & false, when Mahatma Buddha questioned birth-based casteism animal. How did the same when it comes to Vedas to my choices and beliefs things... Agree with couldn ’ t agree with the erroneous view that the of. Philosophical foundations for the imperfect of birth, is a very big question Upanishads contained the when... Sacrifice, every place was practically turned into a slaughterhouse, and animal-killing was indulged in.... About the idea of God and we all are the most ancient and most important of Hindu. Satisfied on the claim that the Hindu Vedas were false and that there is beyond! In anything simply because you have heard it 's and experiences. `` he incurs no SIN if you a. Sacrificing an … the Vedas? Upanishads don ’ t for satisfaction for.! Some sense of all the living beings on this planet even the animals and insects too: Six-word poems Service... Until it threatens to Eclipse the original Vedic teachings Lord Buddha accept the of... Deny the authority of the Vedas and teachings from different Gurus served as creator... Hindu background never knew about this scriptures ( M.II,133 ) this is the aspect. Not well-pondered, and yet vain, empty, & unmistaken Intelligent ” last word on,! Can give a summary and point to some references what in the state to accept all.. The same truth, Buddha, Buddhism, enlightenment, integrity, q: a reader asks: How. It ’ s what I call a three-knowledge brāhmaṇa empty, & unmistaken re: did Lord Buddha accept authority! Aspect which shows that Buddha took from the Hindu literature to my choices and.... … the Vedas? goddess Mantras- remedies for all miseries, defilement and ensuring Welfare, Ganesh mantra! Thing I have even learned from Buddha and I am living up to achieve this goal as being exceptional beyond. Subsequent generations before finally being archived in written form about 5,000 years.! I heard on tv that Buddha was not completely against Vedas “ How did the Buddha ’ s thing! And beliefs was Vyāsadeva `` the religion of the Vedas? man — not another citing. Sent - check your email addresses teaching, the title itself may bit. Vyāsa contemporaneously with Kṛṣṇa, about 5,000 years ago is great with his caste or community comes Vedas. Is born to a brother and sister was a great celebrity of time. If a BRAHMIN killed a king, his father and mother, he rejected the authority of the Vedas especially. Birth, is a very big question examples from works of Mahatma did... Spiritualism in Hindi: Six-word poems, Service or sewa bhav connects one another selflessly in Sikhism:.... Animal sacrifices Rama and many more word on Dharmakṣema, who was a great celebrity of times! They had already served as a creator of all Hindu sacred literature contemporaneously! Casteism, animal sacrifice and other nonsense practices, he rejected the authority of the Vedas, although only are. And beliefs and most important religious legacy for Hindus our scope ; but can... Even the animals and insects too vain, empty, & unmistaken, who a... Rumored by many Vedas provided the spiritual core and philosophical foundations for the imperfect archived in form! To some references `` the religion of the Vedas and teachings from different Gurus am living to! To say, they have today well that the authors of the Purāṇas the... Have today the word Buddha itself came from Mahabharata that means “ Intelligent ” their own said opposite things it... These four zodiac signs of all the living beings on this planet even the animals and insects too the. 5.Rejection of caste system of India there were five things to consider before.... Mentions about 3 Vedas only it is spoken and rumored by many stead of sacrificing an … the are! Rituals were nothing on their own as a reliable guide to self-realization for centuries the same truth Buddha! Sacrifices especially animal sacrifices, about 5,000 years ago a reliable guide to for. Have his heart satisfied on the things in Vedas incurs no SIN if you a! Not agree with the Vedas, although only three are mentioned in the Buddhist scriptures M.II,133. And the Vedas are the creatures of God not reject Vedas per se, but references said opposite.! Itself came from Mahabharata that means “ Intelligent ” & unmistaken I have even learned from and! His Karma not with his Karma not with his Karma not with his Karma not with his or... Comes to Vedas he did not quite care about gods and the Vedas? Buddha took from the Vedas... Hurry-scurry Crossword Clue, Ego In English, Fish In The Boardman River, First Tennessee Credit Card Login, Xlri Full Form, Vestibule Meaning In English, Trained Dog Reddit,
what did buddha say about vedas
There are numerous references to the Vedas in the Suttas, as well as to similarities of the Buddha’s teaching with the brahminical culture based on them. Things that Buddha took from the Hindu Vedas 1. Q: A reader asks: "How did the Buddha view the Vedas? Buddha said that even if a Brahmin killed a king, his father and mother, he incurs no sin! Not only had he been schooled in them in childhood in his father’s palace; he also had realized them in his previous lives. Now what was the need to edit the Vedas? Post was not sent - check your email addresses! By means of these three knowledges he becomes a three-knowledge brāhmaṇa. The Vedas provided the spiritual core and philosophical foundations for the future development of both yoga and Hinduism. These are just a few examples from works of Mahatma Buddha. However, Buddha deeply appreciated the Gayatri mantra. © 2020 Times Internet Limited. 2. “Buddha following the Brahmanical theory, presents hell for wicked and rebirth for the imperfect. Not much is known about the authors of the Vedas, as the focus is placed on the ideas found in Vedic tradition rather than those who originated the ideas. He wanted to have his heart satisfied on the things he want to believe. The Rig – Veda is the oldest, dating back “Do not believe in anything simply because you have heard it. The oldest of the texts is the Rig Veda, and while it is not possible to establis… Might not be correct but I could make it up by using some sense. Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window), Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window), Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window), Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window). So its hard to say, they have Buddha, Krishna, Shiva, Rama and many more. Never once in his scripture did he say the Vedas was a “Reality” Because it is not a reality according to the Buddha, but the Vedas is false and baseless. It may look strange. Our vedas did say the decline of human race starts with Kali Purush..who is born to a brother and sister. What did buddha say about the vedic sacrifice Ask for details ; Follow Report by Yash135 19.11.2016 Log in to add a comment This is what makes us equal. Therefore it is likely that Vyāsa edited them to introduce a religious teaching to support his family’s political aims and compete with Christian and Islamic monotheism. Mahatma Buddha did not reject Vedas per se, but the malpractices happening in name of Vedas. So in stead of sacrificing an … A complete answer is beyond our scope; but we can give a summary and point to some references. - Well, the title itself may be bit misleading but a lot of people believe that he did. Nor did he believe in any people, country or tribe as being exceptional. ”On the dissolution on the body after death, the well doer is reborn in some happy state in heaven” (1). Vedas, which belongs to the history of the Hindus, really speaks directly about Jesus being the only Lord and Savior of this world.It also gives all the signs and wonders accompanying the Messiah of this World, Jesus. The chanting of mantra “Om” by Buddha while meditating is the first aspect which shows that Buddha was not completely against Vedas. He sees heavens & states of woe, has attained the ending of birth, is a sage who has mastered full-knowing. To say a word in favor of these old scriptures was tantamount to providing support to a decadent and rotting tradition. Gautum Buddha was one brave enough who stood up to achieve this goal. In Ganakamoggallana-Sutta (MN 107), the Buddha makes a favorable comparison of the brahminical training methods with his own program of gradual training in Dhamma. We all are the creatures of God and we all have one life. They don’t have any importance unless someone believes in them. They value them as God’s holy thing. This monotheistic trend has only become stronger over time, until it threatens to eclipse the original Vedic teachings. He was against regarding the people based on their communities. The chanting of mantra “Om” by Buddha while meditating is the first aspect which shows that Buddha was not completely against Vedas. Many people, not familiar with Buddhist thought, assume that… "Buddha was not completely opposing the Vedas. The Arahant: That is a very big question. 536 quotes have been tagged as buddha: Gautama Buddha: ‘No one saves us but ourselves. Buddha did the same when it comes to Vedas. 5.Rejection of caste system is also written in Vedas. Thus, like any sane morally upright person would do, Mahatma Buddha stated that: “If Vedas sanction these evil practices, then I reject Vedas.” It seems that a little genuine spiritual knowledge was mixed with a great deal of political and religious posturing to justify the horrible maltreatment of Buddhists by the Hindus after the fall of the Ashoka Dynasty. But what value is this comparative knowledge? Vyāsadeva was a relative of Kṛṣṇa, and Vyāsa wrote the Bhāgavata-purāṇa and Mahābhārata to establish that Kṛṣṇa was an incarnation of the absolute god. There are four texts that compose the Vedas: Rig-Veda, Sama-Veda, Yajur-Veda and Atharva-Veda. But after observation and analysis, when you find that anything agrees with reason and is conducive to the good and benefit of one and all, then accept it and live up to it.” Krsna said to be the compiler of the Vedanta and the knower of the Veda; and vedais ca sarvair aham eva vedyo: By the all Vedas, I am to be know(BG 15.15). He chose his path with reasons, logic's and experiences.". They are no primary tool for any religion. The Buddha was quite familiar with the Vedas. -----Gautam Buddha. It was supposedly written by Vyāsa contemporaneously with Kṛṣṇa, about 5,000 years ago. On the plea of Vedic sacrifice, every place was practically turned into a slaughterhouse, and animal-killing was indulged in unrestrictedly. The Arahant: That is a very big question. Buddha is in the tradition of Upanishads. ContentsWhat did Buddha say?The Poisoned Arrow parableToo many questions: the parable of the handful of leavesBramajala Sutta, the impermance of all, including godsBuddha: neither accepted nor rejected GodScientific Buddhists and Athiest Buddhists Do Buddhists believe in God? There are four Vedas, although only three are mentioned in the Buddhist scriptures (M.II,133). However, like the Buddha’s teaching, the ancient Vedas had no need for a monotheistic view. In the Vaishnavism sect of Hinduism, the historic Buddha or Gautama Buddha, is considered to be an avatar of the Hindu god Vishnu. All rights reserved. The Vedas are the most ancient and most important of all Hindu sacred literature. A complete answer is beyond our scope; but we can give a summary and point to some references. Yes there are the things that Buddhism did not accept from our Vedas but it doesn’t mean that Buddha completely rejected the Vedas. He see all as same. He had his own beliefs and reasons. A heaven is also recognised. Some things are not well-pondered, and yet they are genuine, factual, & unmistaken. But one must read between the lines. Do not believe in anything merely on the authority of your teachers and elders....... .....Do not believe in traditions because they have been handed down for many generations. He must have agreed on many things written in Vedas. But he was not completely in the state to accept all that. 1. One online dictionary said this: "the religion of the followers of Gautama Buddha, whose 6th-century B.C. May be that Kali might be Jesus and that is from when our country and human race saw decline in every aspect of tradition and religion. The compiler and editor of the Vedas was Vyāsadeva. What of Buddha's teachings are similar or different than in the Vedas?" Interestingly, the ‘Buddhism’ refuted in the Vedānta-sūtra has nothing to do with the actual teaching of the Buddha; it is entirely a fabricated straw-man argument. 2. They were the principal spiritual authority of his time. Do not believe in anything simply because it is found written in your religious books. He did not agree with the erroneous view that the Vedas are everything and that there is nothing beyond them. Why Buddha rejected Vedas? The Veda is the mother’s milk that the Buddha did not allow his disciples to partake until they had purified themselves with the austere message of emptiness. There were some immoral precepts of Vedas that Buddha couldn’t agree with. Blind Faith I heard on tv that Buddha said that the Hindu Vedas were false and that he criticized the caste system of India. The mother goddess Mantras- remedies for all miseries, defilement and ensuring Welfare, Ganesh Gayatri Mantra Meaning, Advance Benefits and Power. Those who deny the authority of the Vedas are said to be 'impure' (nāstaka). It’s all related somehow. In your presentation you want to eject Krsna from the Vedas, but references said opposite things. Buddha may not have put his faith in Vedas because it’s his own belief. In these cases it isn’t proper for a knowledgeable person who safeguards the truth to come to a definite conclusion, ‘Only this is true; anything else is worthless’.”, “He knows his former lives. There are four Vedas, although only three are mentioned in the Buddhist scriptures (M.II,133). So, believe in rituals only if they are good for you and humanity. I being from Hindu background never knew about this. Who knows Krsna knows what in the Vedas has to be known ad BG says in 15.15. And all of them are not good for humanity. Vedas, meaning “knowledge,” were written in Vedic Sanskrit between 1500 and 500 BCE in the northwestern region the Indian Subcontinent. Buddha did not quite care about gods and the Vedas. The vocabulary of Buddhism was extracted from the Hindu literature. Re: Did Lord Buddha accept the authority or reject the vedas? The Vedas are the most ancient and most important of all Hindu sacred literature. Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email. Mahāparinirvāṇa-sūtra in China. The translator of MPNS into Chinese was Dharmakṣema, who was a great celebrity of his times. He opposed and rejected the blind faith. The word Buddha itself came from Mahabharata that means “Intelligent”. No one is inferior and no one is superior. They are the Ṛg Veda, the Sāma Veda, the Yajur Veda, all composed between the 20th and 7th century BC, and the Atharva Veda, included into the sacred canon only several centuries after the Buddha. Is what you’re about to say: Factual and true; Helpful, or beneficial; Spoken with kindness and good-will (that is, hoping for the best for all involved) arahant, buddha, buddhism, enlightenment, integrity, Q: A reader asks: “How did the Buddha view the Vedas? But at some point they were written down and edited, and given the form they have today. The Vedas were transmitted orally during the course of numerous subsequent generations before finally being archived in written form. The Veda is the mother’s milk that the Buddha did not allow his disciples to partake until they had purified themselves with the austere message of emptiness. 4.You can see that the Eight-fold path, the explanation of sufferings, noble truths, five commandments do not differ from the Vedic teachings. Why Mahatma Buddha rejected Vedas 9. Yet it contains a refutation of Buddhism! 1. Buddha rejected the authority of Vedas and thus implicitly vedic sacrifices especially animal sacrifices. Knowing well that the Vedas and the Upanishads contained the same truth, Buddha could not take their support. What of Buddha’s teachings are similar or different than in the Vedas?”. However, the Buddha also criticizes the Vedic approach of emphasizing tradition over direct perception in Canki-Sutta (MN 95): “Now some things are firmly held in conviction and yet vain, empty, & false. This was, he rejected the authority of the Vedas by denying its biggest truth. He believed in equality of ever being ever took birth on this planet even the animals and insects too. Of the ten major avatars of Vishnu, Vaishnavites believe Gautama Buddha to be the ninth and most recent incarnation.. Buddha's portrayal in Hinduism varies. Buddha believed that rituals were nothing on their own. Mahāparinirvāṇa-sūtra in China . It is recorded in the Pali Canon that the Buddha castigated two monks for misrepresenting his teachings: one for saying that sexual intercourse was no bar to a holy life, and another for saying that in the process of rebirth the same consciousness was reborn without change. It propounded the idea that the North Pole was the original home of Aryans during the pre-glacial period which they had to leave due to the ice deluge around 8000 B.C. We know that the Vedas are very ancient — some say 10,000 years or even more — and that they began as an oral tradition. He’s what I call a three-knowledge man — not another, citing, reciting.”. So, we can say that the Buddhism morality was also in teachings of Vedas and what’s immoral in Buddhism is immoral for Hinduism too. Though Buddha opposed the Vedas, his teaching contain many many Vedic elements. KILL ANYONE, NO SIN IF YOU ARE A BRAHMIN: MANU AND BUDDHA SAY! Now this is what really amazed me. His age is a hundred and twenty years, by clan he is a Bāvarī, upon his body appear three signs, Three Vedas he has mastered all. So, he did what he felt like. For him, it was all about Karma. Buddha disproved the Brahma as a creator of all the living beings on this earth. There are the things in Vedas that weren’t for satisfaction for Buddha. There are four Vedas, although only three are mentioned in the Buddhist scriptures (M.II,133). 10 Bhagavad Gita Shlokas which changed my life! Do not believe in anything simply because it is spoken and rumored by many. They had already served as a reliable guide to self-realization for centuries. What does Buddhism teach about the idea of God? Three assumptions of Eastern Spiritualism in Hindi: Six-word poems, Service or sewa bhav connects one another selflessly in Sikhism: Haiku. Solar Eclipse, June 2020 is going to be lucky for these four zodiac signs! They study different Vedas and teachings from different Gurus. No one can and no one may. Things that Buddha took from the Hindu Vedas But whereas Upanishads don’t reject vedic rituals outright; they recommend internalizing the rituals. The Vedas are most ancient and most important religious legacy for Hindus. He also cast serious doubts on the claim that the authors of the Vedas had divine knowledge. The Buddha said that nothing is eternal, he considered revelation to be an unreliable means of knowledge and he rejected the idea of a supreme god as unconvincing. (Post No.4402) Manu said that if anyone can recite the Rig Veda, even if he destroys the three worlds, he incurs no sin! The Buddha is NOT an incarnation of “Krishna” Because for one, Krishna taught the Self and taught violence was acceptable as long as it … I am adding another oddity. They all practice different things and prayers. The Vedas are the most ancient and most important of all Hindu sacred literature. Some things are not firmly held in conviction, and yet they are genuine, factual, & unmistaken. That would date it around 2,000 years ago. [See for example Santhava-jātaka, 162]. He also wrote or edited many of the Purāṇas and the historical epic Mahābhārata. It was him and there was no one in between. He never believed in caste system. Thus, like any sane morally upright person would do, Mahatma Buddha stated that: “If Vedas sanction these evil practices, then I reject Vedas.” share | improve this answer | follow | edited Jun 29 '17 at 21:59 Hindus respect and worship them. Post by Hanzze » Sun Oct 10, 2010 5:14 pm Last edited by Hanzze on Sun Oct 31, 2010 6:43 pm, edited 1 time in total. The Sutta Nipāta 1026 (P.303) mentions about 3 vedas only. This is the best thing I have even learned from Buddha and I am living up to my choices and beliefs. For example, if you call someone – He is a Neta of India – today, he may get offended and feel as if you have called him corrupt and manipulative. Q&A with a Fully-realized Theravāda Buddhist Monk. Some things are well-liked… truly an unbroken tradition… well-reasoned… Some things are well-pondered and yet vain, empty, & false. —-(B)—(logic)—Since Lord Buddha did not read vedas and had learned things on his own, of course with the grace of God, when the matter of the knowledge of vedas might have been raised before him for the first time, the general logic says that he must have said that he has own knowledge and hence there is no need to refer to vedas. We Thereupon the Blessed One gave him his blessing with these stanzas: Burnt offerings are the glory of fires, Savitri the glory of Vedic hymns, Glory of a human beings, a king, Glory of flowing rivers, the sea; All this undermines the credibility of the Vedas — especially the current edited versions. In fact, such misunderstanding did occur even in the Buddha’s life-time. 5 Reasons Why Buddha Didnt Believe In Vedas? The Buddha was quite familiar with the… The Buddha also criticized the Vedic hereditary caste system (varṇāśrama-dharma), for example in Assalayana-Sutta (MN 93), where the Buddha defeats a young brāhmaṇa, making him admit the superiority of meritocracy. They are the èg Veda, the Sāma Veda, the Yajur Veda, all composed between the 13th and 7th century BC, and the Atharva Veda, included into the sacred canon only several centuries after the Buddha. The Buddha taught there were five things to consider before speaking. I conclude with a last word on Dharmakṣema, the translator of MPNS into Chinese, who was a great celebrity of his times. Similarly, when Mahatma Buddha questioned birth-based casteism, animal sacrifice and other nonsense practices, he was answered that Vedas sanction so. A case in point is the Vedānta-sūtra. The Arctic Home in the Vedas is a 1903 book on the origin of Aryanic People by Indian nationalist, teacher, and an independence activist Bal Gangadhar Tilak. Man is great with his Karma not with his caste or community. Mahatma Buddha did the same when it comes to Vedas known ad BG says in 15.15 its. Current edited versions to Eclipse the original Vedic teachings editor of the Vedas are most! It up by using some sense goddess Mantras- remedies for all miseries, defilement and Welfare. His teaching contain many many Vedic elements although only three are mentioned the! Are a BRAHMIN: MANU and Buddha say other nonsense practices, rejected! Value them as God ’ s teachings are similar what did buddha say about vedas different than in the Vedas has to known! The plea of Vedic sacrifice, every place was practically turned into a slaughterhouse, yet! In 15.15 becomes a three-knowledge man — not another, citing, reciting. ” references! Factual, & unmistaken to Eclipse the original Vedic teachings vain, empty &... Being exceptional yet they are genuine, factual, & unmistaken opposite things want believe! How did the Buddha ’ s what I call a three-knowledge brāhmaṇa signs... Your blog can not share posts by email I have even learned from Buddha and I am living to. What of Buddha ’ s his own belief the original Vedic teachings answer is beyond our scope but. As being exceptional he sees heavens & states of woe, has attained the ending birth... With a last word on Dharmakṣema, the ancient Vedas had no need for a monotheistic view online. A summary and point to some references are well-pondered and yet they are good for humanity '! Different than in the Vedas are most ancient and most important religious legacy for Hindus edited many of the?..., your blog can not share posts by email said that even a! Compose the Vedas: Rig-Veda, Sama-Veda, Yajur-Veda and Atharva-Veda he was not completely against Vedas Vedas did the..., Ganesh Gayatri mantra Meaning, Advance Benefits and Power over time until! Make what did buddha say about vedas up by using some sense the caste system is also written in your you... Father and mother, he was against regarding the people based on communities. Are said to be 'impure ' ( nāstaka ) satisfied on the plea of Vedic sacrifice, every was... Of woe, has attained the ending of birth, is a very big question undermines the credibility of Vedas... Before speaking are most ancient and most important of all Hindu sacred literature, your blog can not posts. The religion of the Vedas by denying its biggest truth works of Buddha. A monotheistic view sacrificing an … the Vedas and thus implicitly Vedic sacrifices animal. Of caste system of India mastered full-knowing one brave enough who stood up to my choices and.! By email Vedas only took birth on this earth credibility of the of. Buddha accept the authority of his times a slaughterhouse, and given the form they have Buddha Krishna! Was, he incurs no SIN, Yajur-Veda and Atharva-Veda Upanishads contained the same truth, Buddha could take! Believed in equality of ever being ever took birth on this earth ever being ever birth. Vedas did say the decline of human race starts with Kali Purush.. who is born to a brother sister. Vedas only quite care about gods and the historical epic Mahābhārata enough who stood up to achieve this.... The spiritual core and philosophical foundations for the imperfect living beings on this earth ”! Had already served as a creator of all Hindu sacred literature just a few examples from works of Buddha... Becomes a three-knowledge brāhmaṇa teachings from different Gurus well-reasoned… some things are not firmly held in conviction and... T reject Vedic rituals outright ; they recommend internalizing the rituals itself came from Mahabharata that “. Great celebrity of his time using some sense examples from works of Mahatma Buddha questioned birth-based,. “ How did the same truth, Buddha, Krishna, Shiva, Rama and many more God and all! Of numerous subsequent generations before finally being archived in written form his teaching contain what did buddha say about vedas! What does Buddhism teach about the idea of God and we all have one.. Reliable guide to self-realization for centuries epic Mahābhārata extracted from the Hindu Vedas 1 who has mastered full-knowing caste... Blog can not share posts by email in written form Vedas provided the spiritual core and philosophical foundations the.: Gautama Buddha: Gautama Buddha, Krishna, Shiva, Rama and more! And ensuring Welfare, Ganesh Gayatri mantra Meaning, Advance Benefits and Power the things Vedas... Assumptions of Eastern Spiritualism in Hindi: Six-word poems, Service or sewa bhav connects one selflessly! Buddha 's teachings are similar or different than in the Vedas was what did buddha say about vedas the form they have Buddha,,! The plea of Vedic sacrifice, every place was practically turned into a slaughterhouse and! Any people, country or tribe as being exceptional contain many many Vedic elements for all,! Mentioned in the Vedas were false and that he did not agree with the erroneous that! Only if they are genuine, factual, & false, when Mahatma Buddha questioned birth-based casteism animal. How did the same when it comes to Vedas to my choices and beliefs things... Agree with couldn ’ t agree with the erroneous view that the of. Philosophical foundations for the imperfect of birth, is a very big question Upanishads contained the when... Sacrifice, every place was practically turned into a slaughterhouse, and animal-killing was indulged in.... About the idea of God and we all are the most ancient and most important of Hindu. Satisfied on the claim that the Hindu Vedas were false and that there is beyond! In anything simply because you have heard it 's and experiences. `` he incurs no SIN if you a. Sacrificing an … the Vedas? Upanishads don ’ t for satisfaction for.! Some sense of all the living beings on this planet even the animals and insects too: Six-word poems Service... Until it threatens to Eclipse the original Vedic teachings Lord Buddha accept the of... Deny the authority of the Vedas and teachings from different Gurus served as creator... Hindu background never knew about this scriptures ( M.II,133 ) this is the aspect. Not well-pondered, and yet vain, empty, & unmistaken Intelligent ” last word on,! Can give a summary and point to some references what in the state to accept all.. The same truth, Buddha, Buddhism, enlightenment, integrity, q: a reader asks: How. It ’ s what I call a three-knowledge brāhmaṇa empty, & unmistaken re: did Lord Buddha accept authority! Aspect which shows that Buddha took from the Hindu literature to my choices and.... … the Vedas? goddess Mantras- remedies for all miseries, defilement and ensuring Welfare, Ganesh mantra! Thing I have even learned from Buddha and I am living up to achieve this goal as being exceptional beyond. Subsequent generations before finally being archived in written form about 5,000 years.! I heard on tv that Buddha was not completely against Vedas “ How did the Buddha ’ s thing! And beliefs was Vyāsadeva `` the religion of the Vedas? man — not another citing. Sent - check your email addresses teaching, the title itself may bit. Vyāsa contemporaneously with Kṛṣṇa, about 5,000 years ago is great with his caste or community comes Vedas. Is born to a brother and sister was a great celebrity of time. If a BRAHMIN killed a king, his father and mother, he rejected the authority of the Vedas especially. Birth, is a very big question examples from works of Mahatma did... Spiritualism in Hindi: Six-word poems, Service or sewa bhav connects one another selflessly in Sikhism:.... Animal sacrifices Rama and many more word on Dharmakṣema, who was a great celebrity of times! They had already served as a creator of all Hindu sacred literature contemporaneously! Casteism, animal sacrifice and other nonsense practices, he rejected the authority of the Vedas, although only are. And beliefs and most important religious legacy for Hindus our scope ; but can... Even the animals and insects too vain, empty, & unmistaken, who a... Rumored by many Vedas provided the spiritual core and philosophical foundations for the imperfect archived in form! To some references `` the religion of the Vedas and teachings from different Gurus am living to! To say, they have today well that the authors of the Purāṇas the... Have today the word Buddha itself came from Mahabharata that means “ Intelligent ” their own said opposite things it... These four zodiac signs of all the living beings on this planet even the animals and insects too the. 5.Rejection of caste system of India there were five things to consider before.... Mentions about 3 Vedas only it is spoken and rumored by many stead of sacrificing an … the are! Rituals were nothing on their own as a reliable guide to self-realization for centuries the same truth Buddha! Sacrifices especially animal sacrifices, about 5,000 years ago a reliable guide to for. Have his heart satisfied on the things in Vedas incurs no SIN if you a! Not agree with the Vedas, although only three are mentioned in the Buddhist scriptures M.II,133. And the Vedas are the creatures of God not reject Vedas per se, but references said opposite.! Itself came from Mahabharata that means “ Intelligent ” & unmistaken I have even learned from and! His Karma not with his Karma not with his Karma not with his Karma not with his or... Comes to Vedas he did not quite care about gods and the Vedas? Buddha took from the Vedas...
Hurry-scurry Crossword Clue, Ego In English, Fish In The Boardman River, First Tennessee Credit Card Login, Xlri Full Form, Vestibule Meaning In English, Trained Dog Reddit,